Frequently Asked Questions
What is mediation?
Mediation is a confidential process in which an independent third party, the mediator, helps the parties to reach their own agreement to resolve their dispute. The mediator cannot impose a settlement. Any agreement is the parties’ own.
How does mediation differ from other forms of alternative dispute resolution?
Alternative dispute resolution refers to methods by which parties may seek to resolve a dispute without asking a court to determine it. These include negotiation, mediation, arbitration, early neutral evaluation and expert determination.
Negotiation is the process by which the parties seek to resolve the dispute by agreement, either directly or through their representatives. Mediation involves negotiation between the parties with the assistance of an independent and neutral mediator, who facilitates the process but does not decide the dispute. In arbitration, the dispute is referred to an independent arbitrator who determines the issues and makes an award which is generally binding. Early neutral evaluation involves an independent evaluator considering the principal issues and giving an informed assessment of the merits, usually on a non-binding basis. Expert determination involves the appointment of an independent expert to determine a particular issue, commonly one requiring specialist or technical knowledge; whether the determination is binding depends upon the terms upon which the expert is appointed.
How does a mediation day run?
The day usually opens with each party presenting a summary of its case in a joint session. The parties then move to separate rooms, and the mediator holds private sessions with each of them to understand their respective cases and to identify where agreement may be reached. Where it helps, the mediator may bring the parties back together. There is a degree of formality, particularly in the preparation, but the day itself is fluid, with the mediator guiding the discussions.
What is the role of the mediator?
The mediator is independent and neutral. The mediator’s function is to facilitate the negotiations between the parties and to manage the mediation process.
During the mediation, the mediator works with the parties, both together and in private sessions, to understand the matters in dispute and to assist them in exploring whether agreement can be reached. The mediator may move between the parties as the negotiations develop and may determine whether further joint discussion would assist.
The mediator does not act as a judge or arbitrator, does not determine the merits of the dispute and cannot impose a settlement. The decision whether to settle, and the terms upon which any settlement is reached, remain with the parties.
What is the role of a party’s lawyer?
The legal representative acts for the party whom they represent; their role is distinct from that of the mediator.
Before the mediation, the legal representative will ordinarily be involved in preparing the client and the case for mediation, liaising over the arrangements for the mediation and preparing the necessary documents. These may include the mediation agreement, position statement or opening statement, case summary, supporting documents and, where appropriate, a draft settlement agreement.
The legal representative attends the mediation with the client and remains responsible for advising upon the legal aspects of the client’s case and the legal consequences of any proposed settlement. Where agreement is reached, the legal representatives will ordinarily deal with the drafting and completion of the settlement agreement and any consent order required.
How long does a mediation take?
A mediation is usually confined to a set period, from a couple of hours to one or two days, depending on the complexity of the dispute. It can also be arranged within a few weeks, which is far quicker than preparing a case for trial.
Which disputes can be mediated?
Any civil dispute can be mediated if the parties are willing to attend. Mediation is often proposed by one or all of the parties. Under the Civil Procedure Rules, the court may also order or encourage the parties to use mediation or another form of alternative dispute resolution, and some disputes are referred to mediation automatically. A party who unreasonably refuses to consider mediation may face costs sanctions.
Who can propose mediation?
Mediation may be proposed by either party to a dispute, or by the parties jointly.
In some cases, the parties will already have agreed in their contract that, if a dispute arises, they will attempt mediation or another form of alternative dispute resolution before taking further steps.
Where court proceedings have begun, the court may also encourage or order the parties to engage in alternative dispute resolution, and some disputes may be referred to mediation automatically.
What if a party refuses to mediate?
A party may decline an invitation to mediate made by another party. If the dispute proceeds to court, however, the court may take the refusal into account when considering costs.
An unreasonable refusal to mediate may result in an adverse costs order, even against a party who ultimately succeeds in the litigation.
A party should not simply ignore an invitation to mediate. The Court of Appeal has held that silence in response to an invitation to engage in alternative dispute resolution will generally be regarded as unreasonable. Whether any costs consequence follows will depend upon the circumstances of the particular case.
What powers does the court have to order mediation?
The Civil Procedure Rules (the procedural rules governing civil court proceedings in England and Wales) were amended with effect from 1 October 2024 to give the court additional powers to order parties to engage in alternative dispute resolution and to make further provision concerning costs where a party fails to comply with an order for alternative dispute resolution or unreasonably fails to engage in it.
Parties are expected to consider alternative dispute resolution from the outset of a dispute and throughout the course of proceedings. Once proceedings have begun, the court may encourage or order the parties to engage in alternative dispute resolution, and in some categories of case mediation may be compulsory.
When is the right time to mediate?
Mediation can take place before or after court proceedings begin. Mediating early may save significant legal costs, but the parties will know less about each other’s case. Mediating after disclosure and the exchange of evidence gives a clearer picture of the dispute, but by then the parties may be more entrenched and the costs will be higher. A dispute that is not ready for mediation at the outset may become so later.
Why choose mediation rather than litigation?
Mediation is quicker, and usually less costly, than taking a case through the courts. It is private, whereas court hearings are generally open to the public and the press, and a judgment is usually in the public domain once handed down. The parties decide how the mediation is conducted, rather than following the court’s procedural rules. The outcome is also more flexible. A settlement can include terms a court could not order, such as an apology or an agreement to work together again, and it may allow a commercial relationship to continue.
When is mediation unlikely to be suitable?
Mediation may not be suitable where a party needs an urgent remedy, such as an injunction, because a mediator has no power to grant one. It may also not be suitable where the parties need a court to decide an important point of law, where one party’s stance gives the mediation no real prospect of success, or where the court could bring the dispute to a swift end, for example by summary judgment.
Is what is said at mediation confidential?
The parties usually agree in the mediation agreement that what is said or written for the purposes of the mediation is confidential to them and the mediator. The discussions are also likely to be protected by the without prejudice rule, so that if no settlement is reached they cannot generally be referred to in the litigation. The fact that a mediation is taking place, however, may not be confidential, and where proceedings are under way the court will often know of it.
Is the outcome binding?
The mediation itself does not bind the parties. The aim is for the parties to resolve their dispute by the end of the process and to enter into a legally binding settlement agreement. Even where no settlement is reached, the issues between them may have been narrowed.
What documents are needed before the day?
The parties first sign a mediation agreement, which sets out how the mediation will be conducted. Each party then usually prepares a short case summary, often no more than four or five pages. It covers the background, the stage the dispute has reached, the issues and any common ground, the arguments on liability and on quantum, and any earlier offers.
The summaries are usually sent to the mediator, and exchanged between the parties, at least one to two weeks before the mediation. A short, indexed bundle of essential documents may accompany them, such as the contract at the centre of the dispute and key expert reports. Each party will also need its opening presentation, sometimes called a position statement, and it is advisable to bring a draft settlement agreement.
Can the mediator see documents the other party does not?
Yes. A party may send documents or a short statement to the mediator alone, marked clearly as confidential, and they must not be disclosed to or discussed with the other party without that party’s permission. A sensitive point that needs no documents is often better raised with the mediator by telephone before the day.
What does a mediation cost, and who pays?
The costs of a mediation are the mediator’s fee, the venue unless the mediation takes place remotely, and each party’s own legal costs of preparing for and attending it. Each party pays its own legal costs. The mediator’s fee and the venue are usually shared equally between the parties, unless they agree otherwise or their contract provides for it. The mediator’s fee is usually payable before the mediation takes place.
Can the costs of a mediation be recovered?
Where the dispute settles, the settlement can deal with all the costs, including those of the mediation. Where it does not settle and the litigation continues, the court has power to include the costs of the mediation in its final costs order, and it will look at what the parties agreed in the mediation agreement. For that reason, mediation agreements commonly provide that the costs may be treated as costs in the case, leaving the court to decide later who bears them.
